How to Spot a Fake: Ensuring Your New Era 59Fifty Hat is Authentic

How to Spot a Fake: Ensuring Your New Era 59Fifty Hat is Authentic

When it comes to representing your favorite sports team or showcasing your personal style, few accessories can beat the classic New Era 59Fifty hat. Renowned for its quality and popularity, it's no surprise that counterfeit versions of these hats are out there. In this article, we'll share crucial tips to help you ensure that your New Era 59Fifty cap is genuine when shopping online or in-store.

Tip 1: Analyze the Overall Quality

High-quality materials and craftsmanship are hallmarks of a genuine New Era 59Fifty hat. Counterfeit versions typically cut corners on materials and construction, leading to noticeable differences in the following areas:

  • The fabric should be smooth, durable, and consistent in color.
  • The stitching should be even and precise, without frayed or loose threads.
  • The embroidery, including team logos and symbols, should be crisp and cleanly-applied.

Explore our full collection of authentic New Era 59Fifty hats.


Tip 2: Check for Authenticity Labels and Tags

Genuine New Era 59Fifty hats have several labels and tags that can help confirm their authenticity:

  • The New Era logo should be embroidered on the left side of the hat, with consistent stitching and accurate colors.
  • Inside the hat, you'll find the size label, as well as the New Era and MLB (or other relevant leagues) branding.
  • A hologram sticker should be on the underside of the brim, featuring the MLB or other sports league logos, the New Era logo, and a unique serial number.

Tip 3: Confirm Proper Sizing

Authentic New Era 59Fifty hats come in precise sizes for a perfect fit. Counterfeit hats often use generic sizing, such as S/M or L/XL, instead of the detailed numbering system used by New Era. Here are some examples of New Era 59Fifty hat sizes:

  • Size 6 7/8 (21.63 inches or 54.9 cm)
  • Size 7 (22 inches or 55.8 cm)
  • Size 7 1/8 (22.38 inches or 56.8 cm)
  • Size 7 1/4 (22.75 inches or 57.8 cm)
  • Size 7 3/8 (23.13 inches or 58.7 cm)
  • Size 7 1/2 (23.5 inches or 59.6 cm)
  • Size 7 5/8 (23.88 inches or 60.6 cm)
  • Size 7 3/4 (24.25 inches or 61.6 cm)
  • Size 7 7/8 (24.63 inches or 62.5 cm)
  • Size 8 (25 inches or 63.5 cm)

It's essential to measure your head accurately when choosing a New Era 59Fifty hat to ensure a perfect fit. To do so, use a flexible measuring tape and wrap it around your forehead, above your eyebrows and ears, covering the widest part of your head. Keep in mind that hat sizes may vary slightly based on different factors such as fabric type and manufacturing, so it's always best to try the hat on to check the fit when possible.

Tip 4: Examine the Brim and Shape

The shape and overall structure of a genuine New Era 59Fifty hat are often noticeably different from counterfeit versions:

  • The crown should be structured and maintain its shape, even when not being worn.
  • The brim should be flat and wide, with a clean and even curve when viewed from the side.
Browse our selection of authentic Arizona Diamondbacks New Era 59Fifty hats.

Tip 5: Compare Prices

While everyone loves a bargain, it's essential to be cautious if you come across a New Era 59Fifty hat being sold at a significantly lower price than you'd expect. Counterfeiters often use low prices to entice buyers, so be wary if a deal seems too good to be true.

Tip 6: Buy from Trusted Retailers

Purchasing directly from an official store or a trusted retailer is one of the most effective ways to ensure you're getting an authentic New Era 59Fifty hat. Trusted retailers like take pride in offering customers high-quality, genuine products.

Check out our Los Angeles Dodgers New Era 59Fifty hat collection.

Tip 7: Understand the Different New Era 59Fifty Hat Models

New Era produces various models and collections within the 59Fifty lineup, making it helpful to understand the distinct features and styles associated with each model. For instance, the New Era 59Fifty On-Field Collection is specifically designed for athletes, while the New Era 59Fifty Fashion Collection offers unique colorways and embroidery styles for everyday wear.

Tip 8: Look for Precision in Embroidery and Details

Another detail that sets genuine New Era 59Fifty hats apart from counterfeits is the precision and craftsmanship of logos, emblems, and embroidery. Authentic hats will have:

  • Contouring and shading in embroidery elements that create a three-dimensional appearance
  • Clean and consistent embroidery lines without jagged edges or interruptions
  • Accurate team color schemes and faithfully reproduced logos
Discover our New York Yankees New Era 59Fifty hat collection.

Tip 9: Research the Seller's Reputation

Before making a purchase, it's essential to research the seller's reputation to ensure previous customers have had positive experiences with authenticity and customer service. Look for reviews, feedback scores, and any history of selling counterfeit products.


Shopping for a New Era 59Fifty hat should be an enjoyable experience, and by keeping these tips in mind, you can confidently ensure the hat you purchase is genuine. Remember, an authentic New Era 59Fifty hat is worth the investment, providing you with excellent quality, style, and durability to represent your favorite team or make a fashion statement.

Ready to browse the latest styles in official New Era 59Fifty hats? Visit to explore our collections for MLB, NFL, and other leagues. Don't forget to read our reviews to see what our satisfied customers have to say about our wide variety of genuine New Era 59Fifty caps.

Back to blog

Leave a comment