New Era 59Fifty Pittsburgh Pirates Banana Split Ice Cream Pack Fitted

The Banana Split dropped into fitted form — and it melts just as fast. The crown hits in a warm vanilla cream, soft and clean like the first scoop out of the carton. The brim switches to a deep chocolate brown — rich, dark, exactly where it should be. A red button caps the top like that maraschino cherry you always save for last, and the under visor opens up to a bright banana yellow that lights the whole thing up from underneath. The vintage Pittsburgh Pirates Jolly Roger patch sits on the crown in brown-on-cream embroidery, framed in white, giving the logo a worn, nostalgic quality that fits the dessert palette perfectly. On the left side: a Pittsburgh All-Star Game side patch in matching chocolate and cream tones with red lettering — the kind of detail that makes a collector flip the hat over twice.

Food-inspired colorways occupy their own lane in the fitted hat collector world, and the Ice Cream Pack sits near the top of that shelf. The premise is simple: take a dessert everybody grew up with and translate it — faithfully — into a baseball cap. No gimmick graphics, no ice cream cone embroidered on the side. Just the colors, executed cleanly across crown, brim, button, and liner so that when you see it, you immediately read "banana split" without being told. That restraint is what separates a good food-inspired drop from a novelty hat. This one gets it right. The collector who reaches for this isn't chasing a Pirates team color — they're building a palette, stacking food-themed or dessert-toned fits alongside a Neapolitan, a Creamsicle, a Mint Chip. They know exactly what they have.

How to Wear It

The Streetwear Edit
The cream and chocolate two-tone begs for New Balance 550s in cream/gum or a pair of Nike Dunk Low Beige/Brown. Layer it over a heavyweight oatmeal crewneck and carpenter pants in a dark walnut — let the hat be the most interesting thing in the fit. Or go lighter with a boxy off-white tee and tan wide-leg trousers, and let the red button and yellow under visor add the only color in the room.

Her Way
The vanilla crown and chocolate brim work effortlessly with a fitted camel coat, a cream knit sweater tucked into brown wide-leg trousers, or even a summer sundress in warm ivory tones. Jordan 1 Latte or Nike Air Max 1 Anniversary in brown/white are natural pairings. The palette is warm and wearable year-round — this one crosses over out of the "hat guy" world and into everyday editorial territory without trying.

The Collector's Eye
The Banana Split colorway is part of a collector's lane built entirely around food and dessert-inspired drops — a shelf that includes Neapolitan packs, Creamsicle sets, and custom Ice Cream releases from shops like Hat Club and Cap Swag. This Pirates version adds the Pittsburgh All-Star Game side patch as a bonus chase detail, meaning it layers vintage team history on top of the colorway story. If you're building a food-theme rack or an ice cream pack run, this is a pillar piece — not filler.

Explore more iconic fits at 402fitted and dive deeper into fitted hat culture on our Cap Chronicles blog.